A set of stables that was built before planning permission was granted will be allowed to stay after councillors gave them their backing.

At a meeting of Powys County Council’s Planning committee on Thursday, April 7, a retrospective planning application by Jo Sheil to legitimise the building of Dukeshill Stables, next to Hengwm Fawr, Llanddewi’r Cwm, near Builth Wells, was discussed by councillors.

The application was called in front of councillors by the local Powys County Councillor, David Price, who is also a member of the planning committee.

READ MORE:

Cllr Price said: “This application is before us today because the Duhonw community council was inundated with complaints.

“They pressed for enforcement action to be taken on the basis of highway issues which is very substandard in nature.”

He agreed with the highways authority’s initial response which raised objections to the proposal but disagreed with an updated report which showed a change of mind to favour the scheme.

Cllr Price argued that the number of vehicle movements to and from the land should be considered from a starting point of zero, and that all traffic movements should be considered above that figure.

County Times: Cllr David PriceCllr David Price

But because keeping horses does not require planning permission, highways officer Steve Jones said the impact on the roads should actually be measured in comparison to if the horses were kept in open fields.

He said: “We believe it should be based on the greenfield scenario as it was before this development was built without planning consent.

“However, we had discussions with the planning authority who drew conclusions from an appeal site elsewhere in Powys.

“Planning consent is not required for keeping horses on agricultural land and as such we had to consider the existing movements being legitimate, so the comparison is a position we were advised to consider.”

Cllr Price said: “The baseline should be zero movements – I cannot be persuaded otherwise, it’s what the locals see and are angry about.”

Cllr Roger Williams agreed with Cllr Price and believed that the application needed “looking at again.”

He said: “This is a retrospective application, the public view these things with great concern and they see it as people trying to establish a way around the planning system.”

Cllr Gareth Pugh said: “I think people are missing the point we’ve had it explained quite clearly, it’s legal to keep horses on that piece of land, and you have to go and see to them.

“There would be nothing stopping the applicant putting lorry containers, temporary shelters as accommodation for these horses, which would look really ramshackle.

“Based on that I would support officer’s recommendations.”

A vote to approve the application took place and it was carried with 10 votes for and five against.

There was also one abstention and one councillor not allowed to vote due to not being present for the report presentation.